Skip to Main Content

CRJU 1100 - Sumner (Floyd): Evaluating Sources and Research

Introduction to finding and evaluating peer reviewed sources on Criminal Justice topics.

Information Literacy and Research

Information literacy is the ability to recognize what type of information is needed, how to locate that information and evaluate it, and then, use the information effectively.

 

Information literacy skills are required for research.

  1. Think critically about the information you have located in books, articles or websites
  2. Determine the most important information from your research
  3. Prepare your research documentation
  4. Write your abstract or paper, prepare your project.

Additional information relating to this can by found in  Harbrace Essentials, 2nd (on reserve in the libraries), pages 64-80

 
For additional help review this link to OWL@Purdue on how to do research.

 

     

Is it a Peer-reviewed Journal or Not?

A few pointers to help with your decision...

Peer Reviewed Journals are sometimes called:

  • Scholarly
  • Juried
  • Refereed
  • Trade Publcations/Professional
  • Articles submitted to editorial or review board
  • Review masthead

Audience is usually:

  • Reseachers
  • College Students & Professors

Appearance of a journal for some professions is very different than others, rather than black and white pages, be cautious if you encounter:

  • Adverstisements
  • Color pictures

Purpose for the articles can be:

  • Original Research
  • Review of Literature
  • Experimentation
  • Methodology
  • Theory

Format of Articles will typically include:

  • Abstract
  • Keywords
  • Introduction/Statement of Purpose or Problem
  • Lit. Review
  • Methodology
  • Results
  • Conclusion/Recommendations
  • References

How to Evaluate Materials

R      Relevance:                 Think of your assignment and how the information relates to it.

A      Authority:                     Review information about the author or editor.                              

D      Date:                           What is the publication date?   Is age important?

A      Appearance:                Review format, such as text, pictures, etc.

R      Reason for writing:        Balance, research, etc. (Mandalios, 2013)

 

 

 

Mandalios, J. (2013).  RADAR:  An approach for helping students

   evaluate Internet sources.  Journal of Information  Science,

   39(4),470-478.  doi:  10.1177/0165551513478889

Peer reviewed journal example

 

Review this article:

Sentencing Juvenile Offenders to Life in Prison: The Political Sociology of Juvenile Punishment

Carmichael, Jason TView Profile; Burgos, GiovaniView Profile. American Journal of Criminal Justice : AJCJ37.4 (Dec 2012): 602-629.

Article link

©2023 Georgia Highlands College | ask@highlands.libanswers.com